Previously, I introduced the greeting card company, Hallmark, and examined the effect of their campaigns #PutYourHeartToPaperand#CareEnough. My last post also gave
the background of the brand. According to the social media presence and followers'
comments, we can see that their target customers are mostly elder people. That
also explains why these campaigns worked better in Facebook, that is, elder
people prefer Facebook to Twitter. In that respect, Hallmark is blessed with advantages than other greeting card companies don't have because they have
their own TV channel. Hallmark channel offers emotional stories and predicable
dramas loved by older women. This channel has 4,703 followers on Twitter,
more than the number of followers on Hallmark's official Twitter account. These
people who watch this channel seem like the same group of people who would
like to buy greeting cards frequently for relatives and friends. In this way,
the brand cultivated a group of loyal customers and maintained its popularity. Hallmark has the advantage of a massive audience base, but it also has deficiencies.
From what
has been discussed in the monitoring part one, the audience were deeply moved by the Hallmark YouTube videos: #PutYourHeartToPaperand and #CareEnough. These videos were a
good start, but just by watching the video, the audience would not necessarily feel
that they need to participate and interact with the company. In the end, Hallmark
failed to link the video audience with their social media campaign. People
barely discussed the brand with the well-designed hashtag.
As a follow up, I would like to take a look at Hallmark's
competitor. Basically, Hallmark has dominated the American paper greeting card market. What about the E-cards market? I would like to take a closer look at Hallmark E-cards and Jacquie Lawson.
Google
Trend
By comparing the four key words: Hallmark, Hallmark Channel,
Hallmark cards, Hallmark E-cards, we can see that Hallmark's line graph nearly coincides
with Hallmark Cards line graph. Its TV channel and E-card service seem like a
sub-business of the whole brand. The popularity of the Hallmark TV movies has increased; however, the popularity of Hallmark's E-cards has continuously dropped from 2005 to now. Does the descent have
anything to do with other online E-card companies? As we can see from the
second chart, after the "divider" 2011, Jacquie Lawson became the
most popular online E-card company in America and Canada. To explain why this
change happened, we need to take a look at their website and social networking.
Hallmark's E-card designs are similar to its paper cards. Not only cute animated animals,
they also paid the copyright to use popular movie and cartoon characters,
such as the characters from Star Wars, Frozen, and the Badman series. Hallmark's E-card membership
fee for two years is $30. People who pay for Hallmark E-card service usually
send greeting card to others in February, May, and December, which is the same time
period people buy paper cards from real stores.
And
then, let's take a look at Jacquie Lawson.
The company Jacquie Lawson was created in 2002. They offer complex animated E-cards with a distinctive Christian style. We can see from Google Trend, their
popularity rise rapidly during Christmas. In addition, there is one peak in
April for each year, which Hallmark doesn't have. I believe that is because of Easter. In the end, Jacquie Lawson charges a lower membership fee than Hallmark.
Therefore, a big company like Hallmark can offer customers a variety
of options of E-cards and paper cards. A small company like Jacquie Lawson narrows
down its target customers in order to penetrate the huge untapped markets of
holy days. Even though Jacquie Lawson only offers E-card services, they achieved greater
success than Hallmark's E-card.
Facebook
The Facebook account of Jacquie Lawson e-cards was created in 2002, and
they started updating information regularly in 2012. So far, they have 93,250
followers. As we can see, most of the users' comments are
positive. Jacquie Lawson's official account reacts quickly to costumers'
questions, and its answers are usually very helpful.
Unlike Hallmark's Facebook page, Hallmark E-cards' Facebook page
has only 31,379 followers. What's worse, Hallmark barely pays attention to its
E-card social media account. There are fewer updating massages, and nobody
answers costumers' comments. What's more, when I took a look at Hallmark E-cards Facebook page, I found
negative reviews. From the comments, we can tell that audience does not appreciate the E-card Valentine's campaign. I guess Hallmark E-cards wanted to use the zombie
campaign to attract young people; however, it irritated its loyal customers.
Melt
Water Ice Rocket
Jacquie Lawson and Hallmark E-cards
don't have twitter accounts, so the data shown in this tool are relatively
limited. We can see from the chart that they are both mentioned for important holidays,
but Jacquie Lawson is also mentioned on other ordinary days. In my opinion, E-cards
compared with paper cards are less personal. Therefore, E-cards
can be used for greeting small and less important holidays. I believe Melt Water
Ice Rocket shows a weakness of Hallmark E-cards. Since Hallmark paper cards are purchased early in any supermarkets. Instead of sending e-cards,
people like to buy a paper card and mail it to their distant relatives. When it comes to e-card services, people are looking forward to find something
new rather than paper cards they usually buy. The distinctive art designs of Jacquie
Lawson are the magic weapon that continually attracts customers.
Social
Mention
Social mention provides us with a additional look at the
volume of people who are discussing Hallmark E-cards and Jacquie Lawson. It is obvious
that Jacquie Lawson is receiving a higher volume of search, and people who search
this term show 75% passion on continually talking about the brand. What's
more, there are 0 negative reviews of Jacquie Lawson. It means this company built
up a trusted relationship with its customers, and it solved problems presented in negative feedback in time. On the other hand, even though Hallmark E-cards reaches more people than
Jacquie Lawson, it is mainly thanks to the popularity of the brand Hallmark. In
this e-card competition, there is no doubt that Hallmark E-cards lost the
game.
(←Hallmark E-card) (Jacquie Lawson→)
Suggestion
Listening to the
groundswell
Your brand is whatever your customers say it is.
Customers are constantly talking about the brand at anytime anywhere. If a
company is smart, it will listen to not only what customers want to tell them but also
the conversation that relates to their brand between customers. This "listening
skill" is actually the skill of gathering information. With valuable
information from customers, a company is able to improve their product and
their marketing campaign. For the first suggestion, I think Hallmark should create a "listening system". For example, Hallmark can create a voting system
for its YouTube videos, and asks the audience to participate in voting on
its social network. For one thing, through the voting, Hallmark will
have a better understanding of which video their audience prefers, and then they
can make similar but better videos in the future. For another thing, voting
with rewards can effectively connect YouTube viewers with Hallmark social
networking. These events will absorb a young YouTube audience into their
followers' group. What's more, if the reward is
one month accessibility of E-card service, Hallmark will shoot two hawks with
one arrow.
Talking with the
groundswell
Talking with the groundswell means interacting with customers.
A company needs to value their customers' comments and quickly react to them. Good communication should be a circling system. The company releases a topic,
and then people respond to it. By responding to people's comments, the company can guide the conversation and gather useful information. Hallmark Facebook has been doing
well at responding to followers' comments. They don't post automatic responses, and
they answer individuals with their name. However, Hallmark
E-card Facebook never answers people's questions. The first thing for Hallmark's
E-card to take back the throne is beginning to respond to their customers. Furthermore,
form the monitoring part one ,we know that many people felt grief for the love
one they lost after when watching the video of Bob and Kim. Hallmark can
actually create a community for them. By talking and supporting each other,
Hallmark can help them overcome loneliness and sadness. That eventually builds up
a close relationship between the brand and its customers.
Energizing the groundswell
Energizing the groundswell means letting word of
mouth advertise the brand for you. A successful campaign should excited customers
and motivated them to spread the brand for you. As we know, #PutYourHeartToPaper
and #CareEnoughwere unsuccessful at energizing the groundswell. I think what Hallmark lacks a brand
identity. For example, I am giving you a card from Hallmark but other brands don't mean that you are special to me. Revering this idea, we can make many awesome
campaigns which can easily target young people. First, Hallmark can invent music
cards or recording cards that can record 30 seconds of a speaker's voice as a gift.
Second, they can create slogans like
"I am cool, so I buy Hallmark cards," or "A special person deserves Hallmark," or "Money in Hallmark card to grandchildren is a care and
wish." After people really accept these concepts and enjoy playing with music
cards, they will tell their friends and expect to receive Hallmark cards from
others. I believe music and recording cards are fun to play with, so campaigns like
that will energize the groundswell for Hallmark.
Embracing the
groundswell
Embracing the groundswell means bringing customers into the company's development and innovation processes. In short, the company can create
new products using customers' hands. Since each American has a handmade greeting
card experience when he/she was young, a campaign of "designing your own
cards" should be interesting to everyone. First, Hallmark should release
tutorials about how to make relatively complex greeting cards on its YouTube channel.
These videos will help Hallmark gather audience's attention and give audience basic
ideas for creating their own cards. Second, Hallmark can encourage people to
post their card design on its Facebook page. The most popular one will be published
with the designer's name. These two steps allow Hallmark to embrace the
groundswell. Not only will this help to improve their entire brand, but Hallmark can also spread
their social media to the public.
Conclusion
I really enjoyed this monitoring assignment, and I am glad
that I choose Hallmark as my monitoring company. Hallmark is a company with a long
history and interesting stories. I can see that this company maintains a strong
cultural tradition. They have massive resources and powerful designing teams
which support it moving forward. They are on their way to interacting with the groundswell of their social media campaigns. I believe, if followed, these recommendations
could help Hallmark strive for further improvement and become everyone's
favorite greeting card brand.
When I first read the title of Groundswell chapter 7, I
didn't understand what "energizing" means, until I found one sentence metaphor
in the book: "When political candidates get their supporters riled up and
spreading the word, we call it 'Energizing the base.'" (Groundswell, chapter 7) In the business world, it means to keep the customers consistently feeling
exciting about the brand and advertise the brand by mouth. According to
this chapter, there are three steps for energizing the groundswell. First,
the brand should be believable and worthy to talk about. Secondly, analyzing the
customer base can help the company to lock down the creator group. Finally, the
most important part of energizing enthusiasts is using the right techniques, such
as ratings, reviews, and creating a community and participating in their community. It is not surprising that following these three steps a company can
easily tap into the power of word of mouth by connecting with their most committed
customers. However, have you ever think about "crooked" ways other
than these three steps that also achieve the same numbers of loyal fans?
I know one perfect example, that is the movie "Tiny
Times."
I am sorry that, of all movies in China, I introduce you to the "Tiny Times." It is based on the best-selling novel written by
Guo Jingming who was also the director of films Tiny Times1, 2, 3, and4. Personally
speaking, I really don't like them. So why do I take about it?
According to the Groundswell, 23 percents of consumers are
in the creators group, and critics group takes down 20 percent, finally, the
rest of the people are spectators. But for the Tiny Times, 45 percent of audiences
are supporters and 45 percents are critics. Therefore, people who go to the movie theater
for watching it are either loving it a lot or wanting to see how bad it will be. The
most interesting thing about this movie was that it received mostly
negative reviews from the Chinese film critics, although it was a commercial
success.
How to explain this conflict? Let's talk about why some
people hate these films first.
For recent years, many Chinese celebrities
like singers, actors, and authors try to make a name for themselves in the movie filed as
a director. Their first film usually achieves decent box office record.
New
celebrity directors' Weibo followers ranking (China)
Name
Occupation
Weibo' Fans
Movie
Box Office(Yuan)
Zhao Wei
Actress
71.16millions
So
Young
719
millions
Han
Han
Author
41.98millions
The
Continent
632
millions
Gou
Jingming
Author
38.22millions
The
Tiny Times 1-4
1:480millions
2:249millions
3:524millions
4:487millions
Su
Youpeng
Actor
21.36millions
The
Left Ear
470
millions
Deng
Chao
Actor
28.22millions
The
Breakup Guru
666
millions
As we can see from the form. How
many fans this director has on social networking directly affects his movie box
office. When I was young, Gou published his first fantasy novel "Ice Fantasy"
which got the first prize of a novel competition
organized by a famous publishing company. I think everyone of my age had read
this book. And then, he continue publishing works and eventually created his own
magazine company. Therefore, he has a big group of fans before becoming a
film director. Guo is a smart guy who study his fans. He spends no effort to investigate who are his reader. And it turns out 60% of them are high school and
collage girls. So the actors he hires like Yang Mi and Ke Zhendong have fans
with similar characteristics as his readers. In this way, Gou ensured there
will be enough audience even before the movies were created.
Secondly, the key to movie Tiny
Times to maintain audience's enthusiastic is that keeping the audience in suspense. Before
the show time, they release characters' posters one by one, and thus fans are
always excited about what will come next . What's more, the advertising team separate
12 actors to 12 different cities for launch events, in order to reach a large
amount of public attention. During the show time, the crew of the Tiny Times offered
their fans the best participation experience. For example, they create a "trainee"
system. Fans who sign up can wear some costumes from the movie and sing theme
song in the theater. Watching the movie for them is like having a big party. After
the movie showing period, the team of
Tiny Times immediately post tidbits videos and the trailers for the next movie. By
these three steps, the Tiny Times director achieved its commercial success.
From what has been discussed about, the movie Tiny Times team analyzes their audiences and designs highly individualized marketing plans for
them. It is like spoiling children and giving all them candies they like. On the
other hand, this film doesn't care about critics' point of view. In the contrary,
they intently provoked debates between fans and critics for maintaining the hot
topic. I know it is funny. Because what I learned from the books is that the
word of mouth should be the most honest form of marketing. But the thing is
people only say what they believe is true which can be the actually controversy.
As far as there are a considerable amount of passionate people who keep telling
others how good you are, and even spend time and energy to fight with crisis. The movie has successfully take an advantage of energizing the groundswell. However,
it is really case by case. If there is not a big amount of readers and celebrity
fans at the first place, a movie without a good story will hardly achieve the same popularity.
Social
Media Monitoring Part 1: Marketing Campaigns of Hallmark Cards
Hallmark Cards was founded in 1910 by Joyce Hall in
Kansas City. Today, Hallmark is the largest manufacturer of greeting cards
in the U.S.. In addition, it also offers
gift products such as bookmarks, stationery, flowers and stuffed animals around America. Hallmark's creative staff consists of around 800 artists,
designers, stylists, writers, editors and photographers. They launch more than
19,000 new cards' designs every year. Beside designs, Hallmark continuously
updates their operating philosophy. One of the notable changes was that Hallmark
started making same-sex marriage cards in August 2008.
It is worth
mentioning that Hallmark was the first company to recognize Valentine's day.
Have you ever wonder how a company can maintain its popularity for such a long time. As a greeting cards company, it adapted and survived both
the age
of printing and electronics. I think all these achievements can basically be attributed
to Hallmark's marketing campaign plans. I am going to monitor two of Hallmark's campaigns: #PutYourHeartToPaper and
#CareEnough Let's see how it goes!
YouTube
When do you want to write a greeting card to others.
Apparently, the holidays! The campaign #PutYourHeartToPaper was first noticed by the public through a YouTube Video. So far the Hallmark YouTube
channel has 9,912 subscribers. And on January 21, 2015, Hallmark released a
series of seven videos on its YouTube channel "Put Your Heart to Paper",
which range from about 2.8 thousand to 7.6 million views.
This campaign was
originally designed for Valentine's Day. The Hallmark company say: "'I love you' is easy. It's three little words. What's hard is going beyond that,going deeper than that." In each 2 min video, different couples talk about
how they really feel about each other. At the end, they describe their love
without using the word "love", which is moving. This campaign covered
intermarriage, homosexual marriage, and couples of different ages.
Therefore, whoever you are, these videos strike a responsive chord in the
hearts of their audience. The most popular video is the story of Bob and Kim.
Almost 100% of viewers' comments are positive. Some
people admired the love between Bob and Kim, others felt nostalgic and shared
their own story in the comment block. Even though Hallmark didn't clearly say,"Buy my Valentines' Day cards, hurry up!", it is little wonder that people got excited
to do something more for their love one after watching this video.
The most impressive story is the story of Alex. A transgender man,
shared how his Mom's unconditional love and acceptance made all the difference
in this life.
Up to today, this video have been viewed 85,749 times.
Unlike the last time when two people told each other their love. This time, the speaker's mother
was watching in a room away, and then she came out and gave her child a big
hug. This campaign experiment is to encourage people to not only send a
greeting cards for May 10, but also to tell mother the grateful emotion they
don't have chance to say.
Facebook
The Hallmark Facebook page achieved 1,058,937 followers (as of
3/1/2016). It is true that fans of Hallmark do not compare with Starbucks's 40
millions followers. A similar company, American Greetings, that
has 1,291,834 followers on Facebook. It means Hallmark as a greeting card company has comparable number of followers. Personally speaking, I like Hallmark's Facebook page more than American Greeting's because it
is cuter! Hallmark's Facebook is formed by 40% holiday wishes with cartoon designs,
20% online discussion, 10% new products advertising and relative information,
and 20% hashtag campaign. It is amazing that Hallmark pays attention to any tiny
holidays, such as Random Acts of Kindness Day, National Drink Wine Day, and
Love your Pet Day.
For this year, Hallmark's Valentines' Day campaign is
#CareEnough. Similar to their last video campaign; six different couples share
personal story about love and what it means to find your
"Person".
In the mean time, they reposted the video of Bob and Kim
with a new hashtag. Obviously, it was a wise decision to take advantage of the last
campaign's popularity and try to attract more customers' attention. People
seem to appreciate it, so the old video got 18 million likes. Sadly, most of
the comments were about the love one they lost. Hallmark replied to all the
comments and gave comfort to its followers. When the #PutYourHeartToPaper campaign
first came out last year, Facebook not only shared YouTube video, but also
shared relative articles from other companies' Facebook page.
Twitter
Hallmark Cards Twitter has only
1,920 followers, which is very small. On Valentines' Day 2015, the
brand also posted videos and invited consumers to share their input using the
hashtag #PutYourHeartToPaper.
However, even though the video itself was widely spread, Hallmark's twitter
only got a small number of retweets.
There are some differences between Hallmark's Facebook postings and Twitter tweets. First, Hallmark shows stories behind the scenes and
stories of staff. Second, Hallmark actively retweets customer's tweets. Third,
Hallmark retweets irrelevant hot topics. Each of their tweet gets 5-20
likes, so whatever they did before, they need to change to be more popular.
Google Trends
Google Trends is a public web facility of Google. It
shows how often a particular search-term has been discussed online using Google's search engine. According to the screenshots from 2004 to 2016, public
attention of Hallmark was continually descending. It appears that with the
development of the Internet, the tradition of sending people paper cards for holidays has changed. Emails and texting massages have replaced the function
of cards. Luckily, Hallmark found the balance with technological innovation around
2011 and stopped the decline of the trend. What did they do? In my
opinion there were two reasons. On the one hand, Hallmark offered E-card services online. On the other hand, Facebook was launched in 2011. Therefore, all the
campaigns on social network make the dead comeback to life.
When I typed "PutYourHeartToPaper"
into the searching box, Google told me there was not enough information to make a
line graph. However, the campaign did work. Like what I am talking about,
the first two peaks are Valentines' Day and Mother's Day. It is not surprising that their sales went up during that time period. What I didn't expect was the
growth curve at the end of the year. It was due to other two big festival in the U.S., Thanksgiving and Christmas. What's more, Hallmark has its own online movie channel which plays original movies and especially Christmas movies during Christmas. That's why more and
more people searched "Hallmark" as a key word during December. Do you
remember Hallmark's competitor American Greetings? As we can see, they have
been mentioned less by the public than Hallmark.
Melt Water Ice Rocket is another tool for analyzing the
popularity of a particular topic on Twitter and in Blogs. It can trace data back three months. #PutYourHeartToPaper is last year's campaign, so I
used #CareEnough as a keyword. Even though Hallmark Card's Twitter doesn't usually get a large number of likes, whenever Hallmark posts any contents relate to
"love", it will add the hashtag with "care enough," in
order to encourage people to interact with them. There might still not be enough information to put data on the map, let's see.
The video under #CareEnough was first released
on YouTube on 1/19/2015,
and Hallmark's following tweets came out the next day. As we can see from the
chart, the heat of #CareEnough rose from Jan 24 to Feb 14. I think it is mainly
thanks to these tweets from Hallmark. However, the
total number of posts were 12 during three mouths. It means people barely discussed this campaign.
The graphic shows that compared with the brand itself, the word "Care Enough"
is a poor red line lying at the bottom of the graft . Obviously, Hallmark needs to put more
efforts into improving its Twitter feeds.
Social Mention is a simple, useful tool for monitoring
and tracking different social media.
Strength - is the
likelihood that your brand is being discussed in social media.
Sentiment
-
is the ratio of the mentions that are generally positive to those that are
generally negative.
Passion
-
is a measure of the likelihood that individuals talking about your brand will
do so repeatedly
Reach
-
is a measure of the range of influence.
If
MeltWater is a tool focued on Twitter and Blogs, SocialMention covers a bigger
range of dates from different social media. If the campaign #CareEnough didn't
get attention by people on Twitters, has it been searched and discussed
on other social networking?
The result is disappointing. The data show that there is
only a 1% chance that this topic is being discussed online. It means only a very
small number of contents have been produced under this hashtag. And these contents
reached 7% of the people, which is better than the strength. It means a small number of
massages still reach a relatively big group of people. These people might be
Hallmark's loyal fans. The ratio should be the most exciting news. 7:0 means
that all the comments about this campaign are positive.
When I type "Hallmark" as a term into SocialMention,
I finally get a more interesting form. The 48% strength and 36% reach are significantly higher that the last chart. It seems that Hallmark's card campaign is just a
small branch of their business. They release contents about movie and other
products every day. The most impressive point is the ratio 13:1, which
means they have a good reputation and relationship with their customers all the
time.
Conclusion
I chose Hallmark and it's # PutYourHeartToPaper and
#CareEnough campaign as my monitoring project because of their YouTube
video. It was surpring to learned that people love Hallmark's videos, but no
one actually talks about them on social network. These two campaigns did made a
difference to Hallmark as we can see from Google trend.
In my opinion, if Hallmark put more effort into connecting
YouTube videos with their social network in order to energize the groundswell, their holiday campaigns could be ran better.